I find that the technical instructions of Chanmyay Satipatthana follow me into the sit, creating a strange friction between the theory of mindfulness and the raw, messy reality of my experience. It is just past 2 a.m., and there is a sharpness to the floor that I didn't anticipate. A blanket is draped over my shoulders—not because the room is freezing, but to buffer against that specific, bone-deep stillness of the night. My neck is tight; I move it, hear a small crack, and then immediately feel a surge of doubt about the "correctness" of that movement. I find the mental judgment far more taxing than the actual stiffness.
The looping Echo of "Simple" Instructions
Chanmyay Satipatthana explanations keep looping in my mind like half-remembered instructions. Observe this. Know that. Be clear. Be continuous. In theory, the words are basic, but in practice—without the presence of a guide—they become incredibly complex. Alone like this, the explanations don’t sound firm anymore. They blur. They echo. And my mind fills in the gaps with doubt.
I notice my breath. Or I think I do. It feels shallow, uneven, like it doesn’t want to cooperate. My chest tightens a bit. I label it mentally, then immediately question whether I labeled too fast. Or too slow. Or mechanically. This pattern of doubt is a frequent visitor, triggered by the high standards of precision in the Chanmyay tradition. Without external guidance, the search for "correct" mindfulness feels like a test I am constantly failing.
Knowledge Evaporates When the Body Speaks
There’s a dull ache in my left thigh. Not intense. Just persistent. I stay with it. Or I try to. My thoughts repeatedly wander to spiritual clichés: "direct knowing," "bare attention," "dropping the narrative." I find the situation absurd enough to laugh, then catch myself and try to note the "vibration" of the laughter. I try to categorize the laugh—is it neutral or pleasant?—but it's gone before the mind can file it away.
A few hours ago, I was reading about the Dhamma and felt convinced that I understood the path. Now that I am actually sitting, my "knowledge" is useless. The body's pain is louder than the books. The knee speaks louder than the books. The mind wants reassurance that I’m doing this correctly, that this pain fits into the explanation somewhere. I don’t find it.
The Heavy Refusal to Comfort
My posture is a constant struggle; I relax my shoulders, but they reflexively tighten again. My breathing is hitching, and I feel a surge of unprovoked anger. I note the irritation, then I note the fact that I am noting. Eventually, the act of "recognizing" feels like an exhausting chore. This is where Chanmyay explanations feel both helpful and heavy. They don’t comfort. The teachings don't offer reassurance; they simply direct you back to the raw data of the moment.
There’s a mosquito whining somewhere near my ear. I wait. I don’t move. I wait a little longer than usual. Then I swat. The emotions—anger, release, guilt—pass through me in a blur. I am too slow to catch them all. I see that I am failing to be "continuous," and the thought is just a simple, unadorned fact.
Experience Isn't Neat
Satipatthana sounds clean when explained. Four foundations. Clear categories. Actual reality, however, is messy more info and refuses to stay in its boxes. Sensation bleeds into emotion. Thought hides inside bodily tension. I try to just feel without the "story," but my mind is a professional narrator and refuses to quit.
I glance at the clock even though I promised myself I wouldn’t. 2:12. The seconds continue regardless of my scrutiny. The pain in my leg moves just a fraction. I find the change in pain frustrating; I wanted a solid, static object to "study" with my mind. Instead, it remains fluid, entirely unconcerned with my spiritual labels.
The technical thoughts eventually subside, driven out by the sheer intensity of the somatic data. I am left with only raw input: the heat of my skin, the pressure of the floor, the air at my nostrils. Then I drift. Then I come back. No clarity. No summary.
I am not finishing this sit with a greater intellectual grasp of the path. I am simply present in the gap between the words of the teachers and the reality of my breath. sitting in this unfinished mess, letting it be messy, because that’s what’s happening whether I approve of it or not.